What is Pre-submission Peer Review?

 

Pre-submission peer review is a critical process wherein experts and peers in the same field evaluate an author's research to ensure its validity and suitability for publication. This evaluation occurs before the paper is submitted to a journal and is typically conducted by a peer other than the co-authors. This process not only enhances the quality of the research paper but also alleviates the burden on the journal's peer review system.

The primary objective of pre-submission peer review is to assess the merit of the proposed research. It involves a thorough examination of the manuscript before its final submission, aiming to identify and rectify any errors or issues present. The review evaluates various aspects of the work, including the thesis, tone, voice, format, and citations.

There are three common types of peer review: single-anonymized, double-anonymized, and open peer review.

Here are some guidelines for conducting a peer review:

1.    Read the manuscript in its entirety.

2.    Re-read the manuscript and make detailed notes.

3.    Provide clear and constructive feedback in your review.

4.      Make a recommendation regarding the publication of the manuscript.

International Research Promotion pre-submission peer review is a great way to receive constructive feedback from peer reviewers and experts in your field of study.